Apollo Discussions > The Hoax Theory
Hoax? - Apollo 12 Lunar Rendezvous, Dish Falls with Gravity
Mag40:
--- Quote from: najak on November 28, 2024, 05:55:24 AM ---How do Apollogists (may I please use this term?) reconcile the footage of Apollo 12's Lunar Rendezvous where the Dish mysteriously cuts loose and seems to fall with gravity.
--- End quote ---
You're supposed to be a physicist (gish gallup!) what is wrong with it exactly?
--- Quote ---I cannot seem to find this anywhere on the NASA site.
--- End quote ---
It's from the DAC 16mm footage, the clue being it was filmed in space.
--- Quote ---I haven't verified the details yet, but have heard that they used to have this video on their site, but scrubbed it (removed it) after some MLH guys pointed it out.
--- End quote ---
A pathetic statement where you parrot a claim without verification.
Very simply, the dish breaks loose from the force of an RCS thruster. Once the dish breaks from its connector, it sways about for around 2 seconds then it becomes perfectly still. The LM continues to move, rotates a full 90 degrees and the dish stays still. This actually demonstrates how it must be in space.
None of this DAC footage was broadcast on live television. The 16mm DAC camera was used and the film developed back on Earth.
There is just no way NASA would not have watched it through. During the event, it was discussed on the audio recording. They must have known about it.
So basically NASA decides to script a malfunction of the dish, discuss it on audio, then create the scenario to film this incident, and this, according to the crazy claim, when it "shows evidence of gravity"?
It takes a real moron to conjure that one up.
Just a small thing. The DAC footage has the view inverted by 180 degrees, so there appears to be some deception inverting it as though it is "hanging off".
End of thread.
bknight:
--- Quote from: najak on November 28, 2024, 05:55:24 AM ---How do Apollogists (may I please use this term?) reconcile the footage of Apollo 12's Lunar Rendezvous where the Dish mysteriously cuts loose and seems to fall with gravity.
Here's the best footage I could find, but it's not a NASA source:
https://youtu.be/EeeeTVr4Lyg?t=777
I cannot seem to find this anywhere on the NASA site.
I haven't verified the details yet, but have heard that they used to have this video on their site, but scrubbed it (removed it) after some MLH guys pointed it out.
Paolo Attivissimo's debunking site doesn't even mention this instance.
--- End quote ---
I see nothing falling away, the breakage occurs @ ~13:00 of the video, but the dish never falls away, perhaps you could enlighten the group as to whe it falls away to you eyes.
ETA: the dish goes into a shadow and stays there until the area falls below the window.
TimberWolfAu:
--- Quote from: LunarOrbit on November 28, 2024, 11:46:13 AM ---
--- Quote from: najak on November 28, 2024, 05:55:24 AM ---How do Apollogists (may I please use this term?) reconcile the footage of Apollo 12's Lunar Rendezvous where the Dish mysteriously cuts loose and seems to fall with gravity.
Here's the best footage I could find, but it's not a NASA source:
https://youtu.be/EeeeTVr4Lyg?t=777
I cannot seem to find this anywhere on the NASA site.
I haven't verified the details yet, but have heard that they used to have this video on their site, but scrubbed it (removed it) after some MLH guys pointed it out.
Paolo Attivissimo's debunking site doesn't even mention this instance.
--- End quote ---
najak,
I have removed your ability to create new topics until all of your other topics are resolved.
--- End quote ---
I think you might have stopped him from posting in general. He's over on the FB group saying he's been banned, and that he can't see/comment in any of the threads.
bknight:
It's good to not have FB/Meta. :)
LunarOrbit:
--- Quote from: TimberWolfAu on November 29, 2024, 12:55:01 AM ---
I think you might have stopped him from posting in general. He's over on the FB group saying he's been banned, and that he can't see/comment in any of the threads.
--- End quote ---
Hmm. I applied a membership role that was only supposed to prohibit him from starting new topics. I'm not sure why it was preventing him from seeing the forum. I have removed that role. He should be able to access the forum now.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version