The Chinese Spacewalk was Faked.

[Scott]

I know that there have been several threads on the Chinese spacewalk but they basically talked about the alleged anomalies without linking to what they were talkiing about which I think left a lot of viewers confused so I'm starting a thread that shows the anomalies.

http://es.youtube.com/watch?v=NVbBFwdmldA
http://es.youtube.com/watch?v=kG4Z_r38ZDE

In this video the safety cable is obviously buoyant. It has a distinct tendency to to upward.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?gl=ES&hl=es&v=gMxQEHfU6hM

Watch it at these time marks.
0:50
2:10
3:00
3:10
6:08
6:44
6:53

It's going upward because it's slightly lighter than water.

Watch the first video on the list at the 3:45 time mark to see the astronaut holding the buoyant safety cable down so that its buoyancy won't be so obvious.

At the thirty second mark in this clip the astronaut moves the flag from right to left.

The flag flutters the way it would in a medium such as water.

The fast flag movement can be explained by sped-up video.

(1:55 time mark)
-------------------------------

This is serious because the official NASA position is that the Chinese spacewalk was real.  The fact that NASA maintains it was real seriously hurts its credibility.

[dougkeenan]

No it doesn't.  Your claims only hurt your credibility.

[JayUtah]

In this video the safety cable is obviously buoyant.

Are you an expert on buoyancy?  Are you an expert on the dynamics of filaments?  Are you aware that both of those are special fields of study and that the products of those studies would normally be relevant to a judgment whether some observation derives from one or the other?

Or is this just more of you foisting off your uninformed intuition as if it had the power to dictate expected behavior?

[bknight]

While researching your impotent claims concerning A15 flag movement I happened on this video directed to cosmored, one of your sock pupets

It is contained on the page:
http://debunking-a-moron.blogspot.com/2011/07/chinese-spacewalks-part-1.html

[Scott]

Are you an expert on buoyancy?  Are you an expert on the dynamics of filaments?  Are you aware that both of those are special fields of study and that the products of those studies would normally be relevant to a judgment whether some observation derives from one or the other?
 

I'm a layman and I see movement that looks one hundred percent consistent with buoyant cables.  Would all of those factors you mention make the movement so consistent with the movement of buoyant cables that the two movements would be indistinguishable?

[Scott]

While researching your impotent claims concerning A15 flag movement I happened on this video directed to cosmored, one of your sock pupets   

Do you think that person has credibility?  Did you know that he maintains that the Chinese spacewalk was real?
http://www.apollohoax.net/forum/index.php?topic=1149.0

Do you trust the opinions of someone who mainains that the Chinese spacewalk was real?

[JayUtah]

I'm a layman and I see movement that looks one hundred percent consistent with buoyant cables.

A lay opinion is not evidence.

[JayUtah]

Do you trust the opinions of someone who mainains that the Chinese spacewalk was real?

Why would you base credibility on what someone believes rather than his reasons for believing it?  You're tipping your hand.

[smartcooky]

Are you an expert on buoyancy?  Are you an expert on the dynamics of filaments?  Are you aware that both of those are special fields of study and that the products of those studies would normally be relevant to a judgment whether some observation derives from one or the other?
 

I'm a layman and I see movement that looks one hundred percent consistent with buoyant cables.  Would all of those factors you mention make the movement so consistent with the movement of buoyant cables that the two movements would be indistinguishable?

I'm a layman and I see movement that looks one hundred percent consistent with a zero G environment.

You got nothing!